The false beliefs of the Murjiah include:
ONE: The belief that Imaan is affirmation of the heart only (tasdiq),
meaning that one need only to affirm the existence of Allaah, His Tawheed, the
message of His Messengers and related matters in his heart.
Amongst the adherents of this belief are those who include the actions of the
heart which is the majority of the Murjiah and also those who do
not include the actions of the heart in the definition of Imaan and this
the view of Jahm Ibn Safwaan and his followers.
The position of the Jahmi type of Murjiah who do not include actions
of the heart in the definition of Imaan, is also described as
marifah meaning acquaintance only. What is meant here that
one only need to have knowledge of Allaah, His Messenger etc. to be considered a
TWO: The belief that Imaan is proclamation of the tongue only, this is
the view of the Karraamiyyah.
THREE: The belief that Imaan is affirmation of the heart and proclamation
of the tongue only.
Some proofs for this:
The statement of Shaikh ul-Islaam in Kitab ul-Imaan: "The Murjiah
were of three views: The first was that Imaan is merely what is in the heart.
Most of them believed that works of the heart contribute to Imaan, as indicated
in the book of Abu al-Hassan al-Ashari. He also mentioned many other
sects whose listing would be lengthy, although the author states that he has
mentioned most of their statements. This view does not include works as part of
Imaan. This was the opinion of Jahm and of those who followed him, such as
as-Salihi, who, along with his followers, were great supporters of him [Jahm].
The second view states that Imaan is a mere utterance of the tongue. This
position was not known prior to the opinions of the Karramiyyah sect. The third
view states that Imaan is tasdiq, assent, of the heart and a saying of the
tongue. This was the most well-known position among them. Indeed, this was the
prevailing belief among the jurists and the worshipers of the
And from the Imaam Wakee Ibn al-Jarraah ar-Ruusi who said: "Ahl
us-Sunnah are the ones who say Imaan consists of speech and action. The
Murjiah say Imaan is speech (only)! And the Jahmiyyah say Imaan is
acquaintance (marifah)!" (Al-Laalikaaee reports in as-Sunnah
(1837) and al-Aajurree in ash-Shareeah, no.342)
So in summary we have the following:
Based upon these false assumptions, the view of these stray sects with
respect to the various issues related to Imaan can be understood. Some of the
false beliefs arising from these assumptions include:
- That Imaan is constant it cannot increase or decrease.
- What naturally follows from the point above, that the Imaan of all those
tasked with obedience to Allaah (Angels, Prophets, and Muslims in general)
is equal, their being no disparity between any of them.
- That sins can do no harm whatsoever to Imaan, and cannot cause it to
- That one must be certain that he is a perfect Believer, complete and perfect in his Imaan.
- That the most vile of disbelievers and rejectors can be considered to be
Believers, such as Iblis, Firaun
- That the hypocrites are considered perfect believers due to the mere
utterance of their tongues.
It is in light of the above, that we come to know firstly, the falsehood of
the beliefs of the Murjiah and secondly that the Salafis are free from
Irjaa both its beginning and its end.
Two of the important issues raised below include the increase and decrease of
Imaan and also the differentiation between Islaam and Imaan, which is actually a
vitally important point that needs to be understood when the context of our
discussion leads on to other matters such as the futility of performing takfir
on account of sins, and declaring those guilty of major sins to be
The Imaam and Establisher of the Sunnah Abul-Qasim al-Asbahani said in
explanation of the beliefs of Ahl us-Sunnah concerning the issues of Imaan (in al-Hujjah Fee Bayaan il-Mahajjah):
"Imaan, in the legislative sense (i.e. Shareeah usage) is a term
which signifies all of the acts of obedience, both internal and external.
The Asharis say that Imaan is assent, tasdiq, and that actions follow
on from it, but are not from Imaan itself.